In Bayrekdar v. Al Zaher, 2025 ONSC 2713, Justice Mitrow provided clarifying guidance on a jurisdictional issue that has plagued Ontario family law practitioners: whether a court can make final orders for corollary relief under the Divorce Act before granting a divorce. While the Court of Appeal for Ontario had previously established this principle in Rothgiesser v. Rothgiesser (2000 CanLII 1153 (ON CA)), Okmyansky v. Okmyansky (2007 ONCA 427), and Cheng v. Liu (2017 ONCA 104), conflicting Divisional Court decisions created uncertainty in practice.
Justice Mitrow’s decision not only reaffirms the binding appellate authority but provides a practical four-step framework for practitioners at paragraph 83. This article provides a decision tree based upon that framework and adds modifications/annotations to the decision tree based upon the court’s broader analysis.
The Court’s Four-Step Framework
⚖️ Decision Tree: Jurisdictional Validity of Corollary Relief under the Divorce Act
Step 1: Are the parties divorced pursuant to a foreign divorce recognized in Canada?
- ✅ Yes → ❌ No jurisdiction under the Divorce Act
- ✔ Proceed under provincial legislation (e.g., Family Law Act, CLRA)
- 🛑 END (No Divorce Act proceeding permitted)
❌ No → ➡ Proceed to Step 2
Step 2: Are the parties married and has a divorce proceeding (with corollary relief claims) been commenced?
- ✅ Yes →
📌 [Modification #1] Note: Interim orders for parenting (s. 16.1(2)), child support (s. 15.1(2)), or spousal support (s. 15.2(2)) are permissible under the Divorce Act while the divorce proceeding is pending, without requiring a divorce to be granted.
Two valid options for final orders:-
- Option A: Simultaneous Approach
- ✔ Grant divorce and corollary relief in the same order
- ➕ Future changes → Proceed under s. 17 of the Divorce Act (variation proceeding)
- ➡ Proceed to Step 3 for variations
- Option B: Severed Approach
- ✔ Make final order under provincial law (CLRA, Family Law Act)
- ✔ Include provision for divorce to be severed and proceed uncontested (pursuant to Rule 36 of Family Law Rules)
- ➕ Future changes → Proceed under provincial law (variation under CLRA/FLA)
- ➡ Proceed to Step 3 for variations or Step D for post-divorce options
- Option A: Simultaneous Approach
-
- ❌ No → [Modification #2] ❌ Final order under Divorce Act would be a nullity
✔ Proceed under provincial legislation (CLRA, Family Law Act) for final parenting or support orders without a divorce claim
[Modification #3] ✔ In Ontario: CLRA for parenting issues, Family Law Act for support issues (may be combined in same order)
➕ Future changes → Proceed under provincial legislation for variations
[Modification #4] ⚠️ Nullity Warning: Orders made without jurisdiction are nullities and may be unenforceable
➡ Proceed to Step 3 for variations or Step 4 if divorce later granted
Step 3: Is there a motion to change an existing final order?
- 📌 If original order was made under Option A:
✔ Variation is under s. 17 of the Divorce Act
🛑 END (Federal variation proceeding) - 📌 If original order was made under Option B or No Divorce Proceeding:
✔ Variation proceeds under:
– CLRA (for parenting issues)
– Family Law Act (for support issues)
✅ Possibly both, depending on the issues
🛑 END (Provincial variation proceeding)
Step 4: Were parties divorced after a final order under provincial legislation (Option B or No Divorce Proceeding)?
- ✅ Yes →
✔ May bring new corollary relief application under the Divorce Act
🛑 This is not a variation—it’s a fresh application for original relief
➡ END (New federal proceeding) - ❌ No →
✔ Continue under provincial legislation for any relief or variations
🛑 END (Provincial proceeding only)
Modifications Explained
Modification #1 (Added to Step 2 “Yes” branch)
Enhancement: Interim Orders Exception
Addition: Interim Orders During Divorce Proceedings: While final corollary relief requires the options above, interim orders for parenting (s. 16.1(2)), child support (s. 15.1(2)), and spousal support (s. 15.2(2)) may be made under the Divorce Act while the divorce proceeding is pending, without requiring a divorce to be granted.
Legal Basis: Paragraphs [75]-[82] of the decision, particularly [78]: “there is no requirement for the parties to be divorced while the divorce proceeding is pending.”
Modification #2 (Added to Step 2, Option B “No” branch)
Enhancement: Clarification of the “No Divorce Proceeding” Scenario
Addition: Where parties are married but no divorce proceeding is commenced, final orders must be made under provincial legislation (CLRA, Family Law Act). Any purported final order under the Divorce Act would be a nullity.
Legal Basis: Paragraphs [85] and [88] of the decision make clear that without a divorce claim, corollary relief must proceed provincially.
Modification #3 (Added to Step 2, Option B “No” branch and throughout)
Enhancement: Provincial Legislative Specificity
Addition: Ontario Provincial Options: In Ontario, provincial final orders typically proceed under the Children’s Law Reform Act (parenting issues) and Family Law Act (support issues), which may be included in the same order depending on the claims made.
Legal Basis: The final order amendment in paragraph [91] of the decision specifically references both Acts.
Modification #4 (Added to Step 2, Option B “No” branch)
Enhancement: Practical Enforcement Considerations
Addition: Nullity Consequences: Orders made without jurisdiction are nullities and may be unenforceable. Practitioners must carefully verify jurisdictional compliance before relying on orders for support collection or parenting enforcement.
Legal Basis: Paragraph [2] of the decision: “a final order for corollary relief made without jurisdiction is a nullity.”
Practice Implications
Immediate Action Items for Practitioners
- Review Current Practices: Examine standard case conference endorsement templates and consent order precedents for compliance with the framework.
- Pleading Strategy: Consider whether clients’ objectives are best served by simultaneous or severed approaches based on anticipated future variation needs.
- Client Education: Explain the jurisdictional implications of different approaches, particularly for clients who may later want to vary orders.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- The “Divorce Later” Order: Making final corollary relief orders “pursuant to the Divorce Act” with provisions that divorce “shall proceed uncontested” creates nullity orders.
- Interim vs. Final Confusion: Failing to distinguish between interim relief (permissible during divorce proceedings) and final relief (requiring compliance with the framework).
- Variation Jurisdiction Errors: Bringing Divorce Act variation applications for orders originally made under provincial legislation.
Conclusion
Bayrekdar v. Al Zaher provides the clarifying framework Ontario practitioners have needed to navigate corollary relief jurisdiction issues. Justice Mitrow’s four-step approach, enhanced with the practical considerations outlined above, offers a comprehensive guide for ensuring orders are valid and enforceable.
The decision’s emphasis on proper statutory identification reminds us that jurisdictional compliance is not merely procedural—it determines whether families receive the protection they need from court orders. By following this framework, practitioners can avoid the nullity trap while still providing clients with effective resolution of their family law disputes.
Family law practitioners should integrate this framework into their standard practice procedures and review existing templates to ensure compliance with Bayrekdar‘s requirements.
Let’s continue to elevate the practice of family law in Ontario!
Cheryl Goldhart is a Mediator and Arbitrator who can make a difference in resolving your family disputes.
- Four Decades of Specialized Family Law Practice: Cheryl brings a wealth of experience spanning nearly 40 years dedicated exclusively to family law.
- Masters Degree in Counselling: Her Masters Degree in Counselling informs her uniquely empathetic approach to each case.
- Certified Family Law Specialist: The Law Society of Ontario has certified Cheryl as a Family Law Specialist, recognizing her expertise in the area.
- Accreditation as a Mediator by the OAFM: Cheryl’s expertise is reflected in her accreditation from the Ontario Association for Family Mediation.
- Designated ADR Professional by Ontario’s ADR Institute: As a highly respected arbitrator, Cheryl’s designation reflects her recognized expertise in family law arbitration.
- Recipient of Numerous Awards and Honors: Among Cheryl’s many awards, honours and accolades is the prestigious Award for Excellence in Family Law from the Ontario Bar Association.
Legal Disclaimer: See Privacy Policy
Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog post is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered as legal advice. Consult with a qualified family law attorney for advice regarding your specific situation. Goldhart Mediation & Arbitration is not responsible for any actions taken based on the information presented in this blog.

